I updated all the S4PM player pages for this season seeing how the season is almost over and things aren't going to change much with just one game remaining. Remember that it's not supposed to replace any player metric, instead it's more of a head-to-head comparison tool for players that have played with similar lineups, and another way of viewing the +/- lineup data
Also note that PlayerA can be compared to PlayerB if both played with CDEF, but not if A played with GDEF and B played with CDEF, even if we're certain C and G are equally good
Sample size matters here. It's probably more impressive if Player A is +7 over Player B in 2000 possessions, than being +15 in 600 possessions - because of the noise associated with +/- data. The cutoff is 400 possessions which equals a little more than two full games
Strength of opponent is accounted for
Things that may be worth highlighting:
-
Ray Allen compares badly to the Heat's younger guards, Chalmers and Cole (healthy sample size on both), mostly because of his defense
-
Mario Chalmers looks pretty strong across the board. He
may be a little underappreciated right now. There's one player I'll keep an eye on in the playoffs
-
Michael Beasley is all negative. Only non-negative comparison on defense is LeBron... (779 poss.)
-
Dwyane Wade looks rather weak for a star. I'd guess due to health
-
LeBron only better than Ray Allen on defense. Better than everyone on offense
-
Kenyon Martin is +29 over Amaré Stoudemire in 860 comparable possessions. That may be a new record. He looks pretty good on defense generally
-
Bargnani's best(!) comparison is Stoudemire at -8. Worst is with Shumpert at -33 in 615 poss.
-
Iman Shumpert's only negative comparison is Carmelo. Looks strong otherwise with lots of +20s, although some of it is against weak competition (Stoudemire, Bargnani, Hardaway)
-
J.R. Smith mostly positive, only worse than Shumpert and Anthony
-
Carmelo Anthony almost all positive (except for Artest). +30 over Stoudemire, +28 over Chandler (both small sample size)
- Being on the Bucks makes it easier to have good comparisons. Nevertheless,
Khris Middleton may be worth mentioning as his S4PM is better than everyone's but Nate Wolters' and Giannis' (not so great sample size with many of the comparisons, but the fact that almost all of them are positive still counts for something)
-
Nate Wolters has only positive S4PMs, thanks to what appears to be solid defense
-
Luke Ridnour negative across the board. Seeing how he isn't exactly compared to stars he might/should probably be out of the league soon
-
Tyreke Evans is all NET negative. He has one comparison on offense that's >+1 and one on defense.. (12 players in the sample)
-
Nick Collison is another player with almost all positive S4PM. +20 over Perkins, +11 over Ibaka, +17 over Adams and even +11 over Kevin Durant (smaller sample size though)
-
Reggie Jackson is all positive except for the comparison with Durant. Slightly better than Westbrook (+2) in a healthy 2528 possessions
-
Kevin Durant at least +8 against everyone on offense (except for Collison, where he's -5)
- In this metric,
Iguodala absolutely destroys (at least +8) everyone on GSW except for Draymond Green. +20 over Barnes in 2650 possessions.
-
Matthew Dellavedova +11 over Kyrie Irving in 1300 possessions
-
Waiters +7 over Irving in 1300 possessions, due to defense
-
Kevin Martin is all negative.. even on offense
-
Mike Miller with defensive comparisons of: -6, -16, -14, -13, -21
-
Trevor Booker on defense: -22, -14, -11, -11, -10, -14
-
Jae Crowder on defense: +1, +11, +9, +7, +6, +21, +14
-
Kyle O'Quinn is all positive (thanks to his offense) in 5 comparisons with decent sample size
-
Nick Young is all positive on offense. Defense is mixed
-
Beverley +7 over Lin in 3000 possessions
-
Asik only -1 with Howard in 2000 possessions
-
James Harden all positive on offense. Most in the +10 range
-
Hibbert -5 in comparison with Mahinmi in 1843 possessions. -6 of it from defense. That should put a dent in people's 'Hibbert for DPOY'-argument
-
Evan Turner -11 in comparison with Danny Granger (small sample size)
-
Kemba Walker all >+9
-
Kenneth Faried only better than Wilson Chandler on defense. -11 compared to Mozgov, -7 with Hickson, -5 with Darrell Arthur
-
Chris Paul all positive. +7 over Collison in 2332 possessions. +8 over Crawford, +7 over Redick
-
Tiago Splitter all positive on defense, all negative on offense
-
Patty Mills +10 over Tony Parker is surprising (1500 poss.)
-
LaMarcus Aldridge all positve, several (low sample size ones) in the +20 range
-
Rajon Rondo all negative, very much so on defense. Not good on a team as bad as Boston was this season